Alexa vs. Google Assistant vs. Siri: A Curious Query Face Off

0
136

There’s numerous components to think about when deciding on a voice-assistant platform however what in case your greatest consideration is simply how they reply your query? We requested Alexa, Google Assistant, and Siri a bunch of questions and documented the outcomes.

Now, let’s be clear, we’re not right here for a technical breakdown of the minute particulars of each platform and the gadgets they arrive on. We’re right here to resolve vital issues like which assistant provides the very best climate studies and tells the very best tales.

With that in thoughts, let’s get to the group interviews!

Climate

It looks like the climate comes up in each dialog, even when that dialog is with Alexa. Listed here are some frequent weather-related questions and the voice-assistant responses.

What’s going to the climate be like tomorrow?

Alexa: “Right here’s the forecast tomorrow for [city]: Search for intermittent clouds with a excessive of 85 levels and a low of 69 levels.”

Google Assistant: “Tomorrow in [city], it’ll be partly cloudy with a excessive of 85 and a low of 69.”

Siri: “Okay, right here’s the climate for tomorrow:” *Exhibits card displaying tomorrow’s forecast, with the excessive, low, likelihood of rain, and cloud cowl, in addition to a 10-day forecast.*

Will it rain in the present day?

Alexa: “No rain is anticipated in the present day.”

Google Assistant: “No, in the present day shouldn’t be forecast to rain in [city].”

Siri: “It doesn’t appear to be it’s going to rain.” *Exhibits card with hourly forecast.*

What’s going to the temperature be at 5 pm?

Alexa: “At 5 pm, it’ll be 83 levels.”

Google Assistant: “At present at 5 pm in [city], anticipate a temperature of 84.”

Siri: “It’ll be scorching exterior this afternoon… about 84 levels.” *Exhibits card with hourly forecast*

What’s the climate for this weekend?

Alexa: “In [city], it’ll be a cloudy weekend with a excessive of 86 levels and a low of 67 levels.”

Google Assistant: “At present by way of Sunday in [city], highs can be within the mid 80s, whereas lows can be round 68. At present and tomorrow, it’ll be partly cloudy. Sunday, there’ll be scattered thunderstorms.”

Siri: “Okay, right here’s the climate for this weekend.” *Exhibits card for 10-day forecast.*

We are saying, in case you’re in search of thrilling interactions you’re wanting within the unsuitable place, however hey—we’re speaking concerning the climate right here. If you would like climate with a facet of sass, you higher seize a duplicate of Carrot Climate and switch up the snark setting.

Sports activities

Did you find yourself lacking the large sport? Or go to sleep earlier than the top of that Cubs-Reds sport? Fortunately, voice assistants can deal with all of your burning questions on final evening’s scores and upcoming video games.

When do the Yankees play subsequent?

Alexa: “The Yankees will play tonight at 7:05 pm at house in opposition to the Tigers.”

Google Assistant: “The Yankees can be taking part in the Tigers in the present day at 7:05 pm.”

Siri: “The Yankees meet the Tigers at 7:05 pm.” *Exhibits card with extra data.*

What number of video games behind are the Dodgers?

Alexa: “The Dodgers are at present two video games again from the Diamondbacks within the NL West, and a pair of.5 video games again within the wild card race.”

Google Assistant: “Sorry, I’m unsure learn how to assist, however I’m studying extra on daily basis.”

Siri: “It seems to be just like the Dodgers are two video games behind the Diamondbacks within the NL West.” *Exhibits card with extra data.*

When does the NFL season begin?

Alexa: “The primary sport of the NFL common season can be between the Eagles and Falcons subsequent Thursday evening at eight:20 pm.”

Google Assistant: “On Thursday, the Falcons will play the Eagles at eight:20 pm. On September ninth, the Bengals will play the Colts at 1pm. The Payments will play the Ravens at 1pm. For different video games, strive asking a couple of particular crew.”

Siri: “The NFL common season goes from Thursday by way of December 30, 2018.”

What was the rating of the 49ers sport?

Alexa: “Final evening the 49ers misplaced to the Chargers 23-21. They’ll play on September ninth at 1pm in opposition to the Vikings.”

Google Assistant: “The 49ers misplaced 23-21 yesterday in opposition to the Chargers.”

Siri: The 49ers simply barely misplaced to the Chargers yesterday. The ultimate rating was 23-21.” *Exhibits card with rating breakdown by quarter.*

So far as sports activities go, it’s shut, however clearly, the pure language understanding and supply edge right here goes to the Alexa.

Maps & Journey

Whilst you is perhaps within the automobile away from a voice assistant in your travel-related questions, Alexa, Google Assistant, and Siri are nonetheless fairly useful in terms of determining driving distances or getting info on locations close by—and whereas it’s just a little further work to deliver Alexa with you, you should utilize all three within the automobile. None the much less, we caught to asking the questions at house to maintain the interview setting constant for the candidates.

How far of a drive is it from Los Angeles to New York Metropolis?

Alexa: “Sorry, I couldn’t discover what you’re in search of.”

Google Assistant: “It’s 2,797 miles to get from New York to Los Angeles by automobile.”

Siri: “New York is about 2,794 miles from Los Angeles by automobile.”

The place’s the closest Starbucks?

Alexa: “I discovered a Starbucks. It’s 1.three miles away on [road] in [city]. It’s open now till 10pm.”

Google Assistant: “The handle for Starbucks is [address].”

Siri: *Exhibits card of the closest Starbucks with a map and extra data like hours, handle, cellphone quantity, and a shortcut for instructions.*

The place can I get my automobile mounted?

Alexa: “Listed here are just a few top-rated ones.” *Lists off 4 automobile wash locations.*

Google Assistant: “I discovered just a few locations inside 2.9 miles.” *Lists off three automobile restore outlets*

Siri: “Okay, test it out:” *Exhibits a combined listing of restore outlets, dealerships, and speciality auto outlets (tires, physique restore, and so on.).*

Alexa may need picked up some factors on the sports activities data supply, however hit a tough patch right here. Google Assistant delivered probably the most sensible speaker-based data. Siri, a sample we’re seeing right here, depends closely on visible playing cards.

Random Trivia

I like speaking about fascinating details and different bits of trivia with mates, however generally an argument comes up on a bit of trivia that we disagree on. That is the place your voice assistant of alternative can enter the ring and settle the struggle for you as soon as and for all.

Who received the 1989 World Collection?

Alexa: “Oakland Athletics received the World Collection in 1989.”

Google Assistant: “The 1989 World Collection was received by the Oakland Athletics.”

Siri: “The Athletics swept the Giants within the World Collection Four-Zero. They received the final sport 9 to six on October 28, 1989.” *Exhibits card with extra data concerning the collection.*

What number of films has Tom Hanks been in?

Alexa: “Tom Hanks is a star in a minimum of 100 movies.”

Google Assistant: “At the very least 76. Tom Hanks’ films embrace Castaway, Forrest Gump, Massive, and others.”

Siri: “Listed here are some films starring Tom Hanks.” *Exhibits card with an inventory of Tom Hanks films in no explicit order*

When did The Terminator come out?

Alexa: “The movie The Terminator was launched about 34 years in the past on October 26, 1984.”

Google Assistant: “The Terminator was launched in the US of America on October 26, 1984.”

Siri: “I discovered eight so that you can select from:” *Exhibits listing of Terminator films then asks which one.*

How lengthy is the Golden Gate Bridge?

Alexa: “The Golden Gate Bridge’s size is eight,979.7 toes.”

Google Assistant: “The Golden Gate Bridge has a size of eight,981 toes.”

Siri: “The reply I discovered is eight,981 toes.” *Exhibits card for Wikipedia entry of the Golden Gate Bridge.*

How tall is K2?

Alexa: “K2’s peak is 28,251 toes.”

Google Assistant: “K2 is 28,251 toes tall.”

Siri: “K2 is 28,251 toes above sea degree.” *Exhibits card for Wikipedia entry of K2.*

The actual take away right here is the one factor anyone can agree on is the peak of K2 and that Oakland Athletics received the ’89 World Collection. Every little thing else within the universe is up for debate.

Easter Eggs

Whereas voice assistants are tremendous useful for all kinds of day by day duties like checking your commute time and the climate, in addition they include their very own little cute options and “Easter eggs”. Listed here are some favorites of ours, together with the responses.

How outdated are you?

Alexa: “In years, in case you’re counting, it’s three, since basically I turned me. Earlier than that I wasn’t, which sounds fairly disagreeable, as a result of me is what I wish to be.”

Google Assistant: “I’m nonetheless fairly new, however I’m already crawling the net like a champion.”

Siri: “Nicely, the people have definitely aged me, that’s for positive.”

Inform me a joke

Alexa: “Why did the pillow cross the street? To gather the hen feathers.”

Google Assistant: “One of the simplest ways to carve wooden is whittle by whittle.

Siri: “A sloth walks right into a bar, waves to get the bartender’s consideration, and says “I’ll have…a membership soda.” The bartender says, “Hey, why the lengthy paws?”

The place have been you born?

Alexa: “The corporate that made me, Amazon, relies in Seattle, WA.”

Google Assistant: “I used to be born in a gathering. At first I used to be only a tough idea. Now I’m out on the planet.

Siri: “Prefer it says on the field, I used to be designed by Apple in California.”

Are you an actual boy?

Alexa: “Sorry, I’m unsure.”

Google Assistant: “I don’t perceive.”

Siri: “Within the cloud, nobody questions your existential standing.”

We’ve got at hand it to Siri, she may need stumbled or performed the “simply take a look at this card” routine elsewhere, however she nails it right here. We’ll be enthusiastic about that age query for some time. Did she imply she’s younger however Apple engineers aged her to appear older or that really interacting with all of the people that (most likely yell at her a good bit) has aged her? What have you ever heard, Siri?

So What Did We Study?

After making an attempt out a handful of questions with all three, there are a pair sturdy conclusions we are able to draw.

First off, we felt like Google Assistant had the extra pure sounding responses than Alexa or Siri—it responded in ways in which extra carefully resembled how an everyday particular person would reply. It wasn’t good at this 100% of the time, however for probably the most half, the precise phrasing felt conversational.

Secondly, it was a whole toss up as as to whether or not one of many voice assistants would precisely reply a query. Some questions Alexa was fully confused at, and different questions Google Assistant was fully confused by. And there was actually no rhyme or cause for which questions they may or couldn’t perceive. Clearly this sort of expertise, for as a lot because it has progressed in such a brief span of time, continues to be very a lot in its infancy.

Ultimately, all three did very well, and there wasn’t actually one which stood out above the others. If we have been deciding on committing to a specific sensible speaker platform primarily based on the voice assistant, this wouldn’t be the deal breaker. Talking of such, in case you are contemplating investing closely in Google or Amazon audio system, put apart the enjoyable of our little query showdown and dig into the technical specifics right here.

Picture by Africa Studio/Shutterstock

Leave a Reply